Christmas Crabs, Angel Hair, and the Way the Cookie Crumbles

This restrained 2020 holiday season, I have decided to speak of two traditions from my own family: Pasta with crab and Italian cookies.  Although I am confident this pandemic will be over soon, with the passing of several loved ones this past year, I felt it important to memorialize this, in case things fall apart the way so many businesses have.


Over one hundred years ago, a group of newly-arrived immigrants to the Pacific Northwest continued their “Old Country’s” tradition of the Italian Christmas Eve Festa and “Feast of the Seven Fishes.”  (This is a good article from Bon Appetit:  Feast of the Seven Fishes).

For me, as a little boy, and I know for my sister and cousins, those family feasts were magnificent inventions.  We enjoyed the many benefits as well as the drama that comes from being part of a very big, extended Italian family.   The  clan of the nine Polet brothers and sisters eventually evolved into an organization with five family surnames that survive to this day: Chiechi, DeCaro, LaSalle, Orrico and  Polet.  Every Christmas season these respective mini-dynasties have gathered together to celebrate, catch-up and reminisce at Mount Virgin, the little immigrant church where so many of us were baptized, married or buried.

I remember the days when the women (and a few men who liked to be called “chefs”) cooked for at least a week beforehand preparing the assortment of old-country recipes that would be presented the end of the four week Advent fast on Christmas Eve.  The feast was an  abbondanza –  the Italian version of the Pacific Northwest’s potlatch (albeit, without the trading of slaves) – always a multi-course wonderment of antipasti, pasta, sausage, game meats, marinated dishes, seafood, fried vegetables, salads and desserts.  In those days, when the extended family numbered no more that 50 or 60 people, each family provided a main course in sufficient quantity that it could be shared.  My family usually prepared the Dungeness Crab dish, usually served with Angel Hair pasta.

dungeness crab

dungeness crab pasta

another variation of the crab with angel hair pasta (Recipe below)

The pasta’s marinara sauce had a secret ingredient, one which my grandfather passed on to my father, as will I to my daughters and grandchildren.  But the dish is also splendid without it.

The Parade of Cookies – a Dedicated Labor of Love

Before Christmas Eve, my grandparents’ four-story red brick house (a.k.a. “The Big House”) on 23rd Street in what used to be called “Garlic Gulch” hosted many parties during the holidays.   A parade of cookies, the result of what I perceive as an undeclared competition between the women whose families were proud of their cooking, started a few days before Christmas and continued on though the New Year celebrations.

On Christmas Eve each family presented its offering to the altar of comparisons.  The panoply of treats varied somewhat from year to year, but some cookies were consistently present – stacks of my Mom’s crisp pizzelles and almond horns-of-plenty; Grand-Aunt Teresa’s boxes of biscotti dipped in chocolate and loaded with almonds;  baskets filled with Mary Chiechi’s laced pralines; dozens of Grand-Aunt Kena’s honey-soaked biscuits; Auntie Lorraine’s fig and prune mini-tarts; Auntie Evelyn’s bow-tie shaped Crostoli dipped in melted sugar; and Grand Aunt Josie’s fried Zeppole drenched in powdered sugar…and the infamous Rum Balls, from which my Grand-Aunt Rose kept us away, lest we children inebriate ourselves and thereby precipitate a course of irreversible decline and alcohol addiction.

italian bow ties

Italian Bow Ties

more italian cookies

Italian Sweet Fig Cookies

honey cookies

Struffoli (Honey Drops)



Rum balls

The famous Rum Balls that could transform a five year-old into an alcoholic

A Tragic Event 

Perhaps to others, this was much less of a competition than a way of celebrating and demonstrating commitment to the family.  But to my Mom, being considered a great cook in the presence  of other great cooks was extremely important.  I remember my mother spending hours over a hot stove preparing the delicate pizzelles. There were no electric pizzelle irons back then, so she had to bake each cookie individually in a heated press held over the stove.  That process took 3 to 5 minutes per cookie.  I remember one year she stayed up most of the night baking hundreds of pizzelles.   Because of all the time it took to make them, my mother protected the crisp cookies by placing stacks of them into large tin drums.   She then hid the drums in her closet and took them out only when the cookies were to be transferred to smaller boxes for transport to friends and family.


My Mom’s Pizzelles

When I was 7 years old, I perpetrated a long-talked-about, later-to-be-forgiven sin when I somehow  tripped my 4 year old sister, Pam who my Mom had assigned to carry the big tin of pizzelles from the closet.    Pam hit my foot (accidentally in the way, of course) and stumbled, sending the tin drum flying.   I can still hear my mom shrieking, the tin drum clunking down the steps, and the sounds of the delicate, lacy pizzelles inside the drum being rendered into unpresentable tiny shards.   Quite an opera scene.  Pam says she doesn’t remember that episode, thank goodness.  But, despite confession, I still carry the guilt, as is my due.


Although we no longer gather the extended Polet family on Christmas Eve, the Polet Family Association continues the annual tradition with a party in December, invariably attended by well over 100-150 people of all ages.  This year, unfortunately, we must interrupt that tradition.  

I accept that I am now one of the elders in that gathering.  The extremely interesting  23 and Me genetics program has introduced me to relatives all over the world, almost all of whom I will never meet in person.    Here in Seattle at these annual events however, I have the pleasure of meeting  sixth and seventh cousins!   I personally know fewer and fewer of the attendees, but it doesn’t matter, because we are all celebrating a tradition.  My job, as an elder, is to convey to them why it is so important.

Each year at that event I examine the large Christmas tree decorated with small pictures of all of our now deceased loved ones.  As I do that, I am more and more aware that life passes very quickly indeed. Watching all of the beautiful  little children sitting with Santa, as I did once upon a time, makes me grateful for traditions like this, for such rituals tie our lives together in a very special way,  by providing continuity to all our lives.  The observance of family traditions keep families alive.

Things Change

Our large extended family inevitably has diversified into a less and less connected community of relatives over the years.  It has incorporated other cultures into itself, Many of our family’s traditions have been replaced by those of others.    In many cases, the symbolic observances have been forgotten altogether.    For example, at the Polet annual dinner, the fare is less and less about Italian food.   I realized that the  food was simply an expendable accoutrement to the real purpose of the traditional gathering which is more about catching up with relatives, refreshing our understanding of how the complex family tree looks, retelling hilarious stories and reawakening cherished memories.

And sometimes we are lucky enough to hear stories we haven’t been told before.  For example, last year, before she passed away, my dear cousin Celine  (CeCe) Patricelli-Cimino, God rest her soul, told us the story about how, in the summer of ’52,  she watched our hilariously, notoriously wicked cousin, Frankie DeCaro, tease Grand- Aunt Rose to stop nagging him about his improprieties.  Rose, who I recall, was a very tidy person,  had just chastised Frankie for going shirtless on a very hot summer day.  “You are scandalizing the girls  with your display of all that disgusting chest hair”  she had complained.  As she went on about it,  Frankie casually pulled out a lighter and set his chest hair on fire.  “There!  Happy now?” he said, as all the girls in the family squealed in laughter.  I imagine Aunt Rose didn’t bother him again after that.  CeCe’s story brought Frankie to life again for me, as well as those at the party who remember him.

On this Christmas Eve, in the confines of an intimate gathering,  we will honor the LaSalle family tradition with Pizzelles and Crab with Angel Hair pasta (and, perhaps a few other fish recipes).

For you, my own extended community of friends, I pass on these two recipes and hope you will find them as wonderful as I do. Perhaps they can become part of your family traditions as well.

RECIPE:  Dungeness Crab and Angel Hair Pasta

Prepare your favorite meatless marinara sauce.

Clean Dungeness crabs (1 crab for every 2 persons).  Break off legs and quarter the caprice.  Crack shells with a mallet before placing in marinara sauce.  Saute crab in sauce for at least 30 to 60 minutes.  Separate crab from sauce.

Cook Angel Hair pasta until al dente.  Drain well.  Add sauce.

Serve Crab separately.  Provide plenty of napkins. Crab-crackers & forks.

An excellent, simple Variation:  Dungeness crab pasta w butter, garlic and olive oil.

RECIPE:  Italian Pizzelles

NB:  Essential:   Pizzelle iron, Anise oil.


  1. Steve McAlpine on December 13, 2020 at 10:02 am

    Hi Gar:
    For many years my family celebrated Feast of Seven Fishes. This year like so many other families we will not be physically present with extended family and friends. When we reach out through story or technology we keep family traditions and friends alive. Thanks for reminding me of both. May you and your family be blessed by God this season.
    To God, family, friends and tradition; May this be a toast for your holiday table that they all live forever in each of us.

    • GarLaSalle on December 20, 2020 at 11:42 am

      Steve: So good to hear from you! I hope you are doing well and blessed holidays and new year to you and your family.

  2. Mike Colacarro on December 13, 2020 at 11:22 am

    Great stories. Yes Easter and Xmas feasts were something to enjoy with family. How many courses? Too many.

    • GarLaSalle on December 20, 2020 at 11:41 am

      Hey Mike…thinking about you lately as you have become a repository of information about our classmates at St. Paul. Yes…too many courses, followed by the women in the kitchen sitting around and sharing gossip and the men smoking cigars playing poker on the long table. the movie”The Big Night” captures the abbondanza aftermath pretty well. Best to you.

      P.S. I really would like to know whatever happened to Linda Pizzella, Kathleen Lidman, Linda Gese, Ann Stevens, Helen Ramsey and Mary Fox…Perhaps we can have coffee some time to catch up.

  3. Vincent Mazzaferro on December 14, 2020 at 5:51 pm

    Where can we find the recipes for all those wonderful Italian cookies

    • GarLaSalle on December 20, 2020 at 11:33 am

      Vincent: I think you will find them on a google search if you click on the names. Several people have sent me variations on the recipes. Be careful with the rum balls. Happy holidays.

  4. Natalie Radford on December 15, 2020 at 1:34 pm

    Making some pizzelles for Christmas today. Thank you for this family story.
    Merry Christmas Gar!!!

    • GarLaSalle on December 20, 2020 at 11:31 am

      Merry Christmas, Natalie! Don’t forget the anise oil.

  5. Frank Mitchell on December 16, 2020 at 9:29 pm

    Gar, this is very sweet. I am forwarding it to Mary Ann Draye (Trettenero) who knows Pam from the Christmas programs they put on every year at the church. I can’t imagine you tripping Pam, what did your blessed and wonderful dad say about that? I hope his picture is on the tree, just thinking about him makes me teary eyed. I really loved him.

    • GarLaSalle on December 20, 2020 at 11:31 am

      Frank, so good to hear from you. Yes, I saw Dad’s picture on the tree for the first time last year. Moved me. He loved you too, Frank. Hope to see you in ’21. Happy Christmas and New Year.

  6. Lee on December 17, 2020 at 4:27 am

    Darling story Gar. Making the crab angelhair!

    • GarLaSalle on December 20, 2020 at 11:28 am

      Let me know how you like it. Try just cooking the shells in the sauce (with the “mustard”) wrapped in cheesecloth. You might like that as well.

  7. Susan Budassi Sheehy on December 17, 2020 at 2:28 pm

    Love your writing. Brought back many memories of my childhood in my Italian neighborhood of “The Burg” in Trenton, NJ. My grandmother Nonna) would take out a huge board with a lip on it and place it on the kitchen table. She poured out a 5 pound bag of flour and lots of eggs and kneaded the mixture until
    It became a lovely giant ball of dough. The she would take a long stick and roll it across the dough until it became a giant paper thin circle. She rolled up the circle into a giant long skinny jelly roll-like thing and then cut across it as fast as I have ever seen anyone cut something, forming what seemed like hundreds of thin jelly roll slices.the slices were unraveled and the thin strings of what had now become macaroni ( aka, pasta) which were draped over wine hangars and hing all around our kitchen to dry.

    My job was to grate the cheese -only Pecorino/ Romano was ever permitted. I used a grater that looked like a small washboard. I new when my job was done when my knuckles scraped the sharp points in the grater. My reward was that I could eat the small piece of cheese left in my little fingers.

    We had crabs as well, in the gravy (aka sauce). Only, living on the east coast, we had Maryland Blue crabs – certainly a misnomer, because they thrived in the ocean off of the Delaware and Jersey shores.

    Thank you for helping me remember. Made me smile a whole bunch. Happy and safe holidays, everyone.

    • GarLaSalle on December 20, 2020 at 11:25 am

      Sue: Thank you. We both had the job of grating the cheese. I didn’t realize the job was done when I scraped my knuckles. And yes, I got the rind as a reward…that and a few band-aids. Hope you are doing well, my young friend. Happy holidays! BTW…haven’t heard back from your son. Hope he is still writing.

  8. Kathleen Emde on December 17, 2020 at 6:31 pm

    Hello Gar. Thank you for sharing your family’s long history of celebrating our families. It brings to mind the very large holiday gatherings. Everyone knew to avoid Aunt Marie’s lumpy gravy, and to gather together to hear Grandpa Palmer sing old Irish songs which he recalled from his childhood. I appreciate your sharing of your story. which reminded me of family members gone as well as those wonderful people who remai.

    • GarLaSalle on December 20, 2020 at 11:21 am

      Thank you, Kathy. Record those memories for your future generations! Happy Holidays!

  9. Tim on December 18, 2020 at 4:26 pm

    Gar! Love it! Thank you for sharing about your family history. I know that our family has become so fractured that we only see a fraction of our relatives any more and as I get older I find myself missing those times more.
    Merry Christmas to you and your family!

  10. Lilli Scalzo - Pietromonaco on December 18, 2020 at 10:51 pm

    Thank you for sharing. The story is so similar to my own family’s. It makes me happy and sad, at the same time. Grateful for what I had and missing those who made it all possible.

    • GarLaSalle on December 20, 2020 at 11:22 am

      Lilli: I agree…record the stories for your future generations. Happy holidays!

  11. Lisa Courtney on December 22, 2020 at 5:49 am

    Hi, Gar, what a great story! You are the gifted story teller for sure. The food looks amazing. I am sure you have many more stories to tell and I look forward to reading them!

    Happy Holidays,

    Lisa Courtney

  12. Lynn Massingale on December 26, 2020 at 4:54 pm

    Gar, sorry for my late posting but thank you for sharing these memories and these fabulous recipes! Most of us are fortunate in having had close knit and loving families and your stories resonate always, but especially this time of year. All the best to you and your family as we all look forward to a better 2021!

  13. Dorene Centioli McTigue on December 27, 2020 at 10:17 am

    Dear Gar,

    Happy St. Stephen’s Day. My siblings, Phyllis Centioli Biesold, Gloria Centioli Sauro, and Gerard Centioli, and I never tire of stories about the family. Your memoir adds charming texture and neglected detail to our recollection of Christmas at Mt. Virgin. Thank you.

    The three Centioli sisters and their progeny make slightly different pizzelle without ever acknowledging the (possible) superiority, let alone adequacy, of competitive offerings. For years, we all gathered a week before Christmas to make grease-soaked and heavily-frosted scaletti, which we secured in Mom’s 10-gallon tin. The shared effort while bumping into each other in a crowded kitchen was joyous; however we ultimately decided to skip the calories. This year, some in the younger generation pleased us old timers by saying that they intend the return of the scalleti.

    The Centioli group numbers about thirty. On Christmas Eve, every household has the same once-a-year meal: home-made antipasto; uncracked crab; and fresh crab pasta in a crab sauce made the day before. We like to get together on Christmas evening, an impossibility in 2020. To compensate a tad, this year the sauce and the antipasto base were made at one kitchen and delivered to each Seattle household so that, at least in the fashion of this weirdest of years, we can share the same meal. The traditional food made us feel closer despite the covid isolation. If traditional foods are not themselves magic, our response to them surely must be.

    Buon natale e felice anno nuovo,

    Dorene Centioli McTigue

  14. JoAnn on December 21, 2021 at 12:40 pm

    Hi Gar, Such a heartwarming story. It provoked a sense of nostalgia for my beloved Shanghai and my memories of my childhood holidays. Although we didn’t grow up with abundance, and our recipes were different, the anticipation, the family atmosphere, and the sentiments are the same. We also had our version of what one commentator referred to as ”Aunt Marie’s lumpy gravy” to avoid.

    I hope Frankie, God rests his soul, can proudly and freely display his chest fur in heaven without the interference of Aunt Rose, unless Aunt Rose chased him to the heaven too.

    Love this story. Thanks for showing me how to accomplish a blog piece.